한국어

Is Note-Taking a Waste of Time? What the Research Says

At a glance
  • Note-taking is not a waste of time, but the benefit of writing things down by itself is modest.
  • Most of the value shows up when you go back to your notes and review them.
  • With equal study time, students who mapped a text with it open scored 45% a week later; those who closed it and recalled scored 67%.
  • 84% of 120 students learned more from recalling, yet 75% expected organizing to work as well or better.
  • Keep notes short. To review, close them, write what you remember on a blank page, then fill the gaps from your notes.

Note-taking is not a waste of time. But writing things down helps only a little on its own; most of the value comes when you review what you wrote. And how you review matters. With the same amount of time, students who closed the text and recalled it remembered far more a week later than students who organized it with the text open.

Is note-taking a waste of time?

No. Taking notes helps a little, and reviewing them helps a lot more.

Kobayashi (2005) pooled 57 studies that compared taking notes with not taking notes. The benefit of note-taking alone was positive but modest. Teaching students better note-taking techniques did not make it larger, and when material was presented visually, it got in the way of note-taking. The analysis traced the small effect not to poor technique but to the mechanical load of writing things down, and to the kind of test used. The effect showed up most on tests that asked students to recall.

A year later the same researcher pooled 33 studies in which students both took notes and reviewed them (Kobayashi 2006). Taking and reviewing notes together had a substantial effect. Among the ways to help, giving students a framework or the instructor's notes did more than training or instructions alone.

So the value of notes sits less in the moment you write them and more in the moment you use them again. Notes you never reread, and hours spent recopying them into a neat version, are the closest thing to wasted time.

Is rewriting your notes neatly a waste of time?

Compared with recalling, mostly yes, if the source is open while you do it. There is little to pull from memory, and the same time spent recalling paid off more a week later.

Karpicke and Blunt (2011, Science) split 80 college students into four groups and had them learn a science text. Compare two of the groups. One read the text and then built a concept map with the text in front of them: concepts in circles, lines for how they relate, the textbook way to organize material. The other read the text, put it away, wrote down everything they could recall, read it again, and recalled again. Total learning time was matched exactly. A week later both took a short-answer test with questions stated directly in the text and questions that required connecting several ideas.

Both groups wrote down as much at first, but a week later the recall group scored higher

  • Concept map, text open
  • Recall, text closed
0%25%50%75%100%Concept map, text open · Ideas written while learning · 78%78%Recall, text closed · Ideas written while learning · 81%81%Ideas writtenwhile learningConcept map, text open · Test score one week later · 45%45%Recall, text closed · Test score one week later · 67%67%Test scoreone week laterSame time spent,67% vs 45%
Left, the share of the text's ideas students produced during learning, on their concept maps or recall sheets. Right, proportion correct on the short-answer test one week later (verbatim and inference questions combined). Learning time was the same for both groups.Source: Karpicke & Blunt (2011), Experiment 1 text
See the numbers
Concept map, text openRecall, text closed
Ideas written while learning78%81%
Test score one week later45%67%

During learning, the two groups wrote down nearly the same share of ideas (78% and 81%). A week later, the recall group scored 67% and the concept mapping group 45%, a difference of about one and a half standard deviations. Concept mapping was not significantly better than simply rereading the text several times. The pattern held for the inference questions too.

The authors put it plainly: whether an activity counts as "active" does not tell you how much it will teach you. Organizing feels like work, and it is work, but it is a different kind of work from pulling knowledge out of your own head.

In one line With the source open, organizing is copying. With the source closed, it becomes remembering.

Do mind maps and concept maps not work?

They work when you draw them from memory. The problem is not the map; it is drawing it with the book open.

In the second experiment of the same paper, 120 students learned one text by concept mapping and another by recall. Half of them took a final test in which they had to draw a concept map from memory, a test that looks like it should favor the mapping practice. Students still did better on the text they had recalled. The authors add that a concept map drawn without the text in view is itself a form of retrieval practice.

So if you like mind maps, keep them. Close the book, draw the map on a blank page, then open the book and add the missing branches in a different color.

Why does organizing feel like it works better?

Because while you organize, everything is in front of you, and it feels like you know it. That feeling did not predict what students remembered a week later.

In the second experiment the researchers compared the two methods for each student, and right after studying they asked which text each student expected to remember better.

101 of 120 students did better after recalling, but only 30 predicted it

  • Actual result
  • Prediction after studying
0306090120Actual result · Recall better · 101101Prediction after studying · Recall better · 3030RecallbetterActual result · Same · 66Prediction after studying · Same · 3131SameActual result · Concept map better · 1313Prediction after studying · Concept map better · 5959Concept mapbetter
Number of students, comparing each student's two texts. "Actual result" is the final test score; "Prediction after studying" is the judgment made right after learning.Source: Karpicke & Blunt (2011), Experiment 2, Table 1
See the numbers
Actual resultPrediction after studying
Recall better10130
Same631
Concept map better1359

101 of 120 students (84%) remembered more of the text they had recalled. Yet 90 of the 120 (75%) predicted that concept mapping would work as well or better. In the first experiment, students predicted that rereading would be best and recall worst. The results ran the other way.

A review of ten common study techniques by Dunlosky and colleagues (2013) points the same way.

What students often doRating in Dunlosky et al. (2013)
Practice testing (recalling)High utility
Spacing study over timeHigh utility
SummarizingLow utility
Highlighting and underliningLow utility
RereadingLow utility

Rereading and highlighting are what most students report doing, yet they did not consistently improve performance, and summarizing helped only under limited conditions. The authors recommend practice testing in place of rereading.

Is handwriting notes better than typing?

It is not settled. Studies disagree.

The idea that longhand beats a laptop spread from an experiment by Mueller and Oppenheimer (2014). When Morehead, Dunlosky, and Rawson (2019) ran it again, they found no consistent difference between longhand and laptop, or even between either of them and a group that took no notes at all, and the gaps shrank further once students studied their notes. On the other side, a meta-analysis of 24 studies of college lecture notes by Flanigan and colleagues (2024) found that taking and reviewing handwritten notes led to slightly higher achievement (Hedges' g = 0.25), while typing let students write down much more.

Either way, the tool you write with matters much less than what you do with the notes afterwards. The 67% against 45% above is the size of that difference.

How should you take notes, starting today?

Spend less time writing and more time closing the notes and recalling.

  1. Keep notes short while you read or listen. Instead of copying sentences, write one question and a few key words. You do not need a recopied "clean version".
  2. To review, close your notes and write on a blank page. Write down what you remember from today, or answer the questions you left in the margin.
  3. Open the notes and fill the gaps in another color. What you missed or got wrong is what you do not know yet. Start there next time.
  4. Do it again a few days later. The students in the experiment recalled, reread, and recalled again. For when to come back, see the note on spaced repetition schedules.

The same goes for AI summaries. A summary is something to read; memory forms when you close it and recall. For the order to use AI in, see Is using ChatGPT to study bad?.

In Aloom

In Aloom there is no clean version to make. You ask AI, keep only the answers worth keeping, and each one joins what you already know in your knowledge graph. That is where organizing ends; the rest of your time goes to recall. Each day, 1, 3, or 5 kept answers come back as questions, and you recall before you see the answer: the close-and-recall step from this note, done daily. The more you recall a node, the darker its ink. Take a look at Aloom

FAQ

Is rewriting notes a waste of time?

Recopying notes with the original open is mostly copying, and copying left students well behind recall in the study above. If you want to rewrite, do it from memory first, then check against the original. That turns rewriting into recall.

Does taking notes help you remember?

A little. Across 57 studies the effect of note-taking alone was positive but modest. Taking notes and then reviewing them had a much larger effect, and reviewing by recall works better than rereading.

Is it better not to take notes at all?

No. Notes give you something to check your recall against, so you can find and fix what you got wrong. Keep them short and spend the saved time recalling.

References